external-links:: [SCP OSP Special Issue - Google Sheets](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1h1j-bzCar2_Kxk1PEFeuioX_qV86HYxea9-jzcJ0DAw/edit#gid=0) [SCP OSP Special Issue - Google Sheets](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1h1j-bzCar2_Kxk1PEFeuioX_qV86HYxea9-jzcJ0DAw/edit#gid=0)

	- ## Evaluation criteria
		- i. *Originality and novelty*. This means the software should not be published in its current form elsewhere. If comparable systems exist, the short paper should explicitly point out in which aspects or why the submitted software is unique.
		- ii. *Impact on the scientific process and significant  in the area of computer programming and software engineering research*. This may also involve educational aspects of programming or software engineering. Just a nice piece of code is not sufficient for acceptance.
		- iii. *Quality, completeness, and readability of the source code* if available.
		- iv. *Available, and easy to install and work*. A system that does not fulfil these simple criteria should be immediately rejected. Working means not just starting but one should be able to perform tasks for which the system was built.
		- v. *Well documented*. One can think of a user manual, installation guide, for example.
		- vi. *Reproducibility of the empirical results*  Results shown in tables and figures can be reproduced by reviewer and users.
	- ## Under my responsibility
		- |ID|Review 1|Review 2|Review 3|My Recommendation| [[Notes]] |
		  | ==SCICO-D-22-00353== | Reject | Major | Under [[Comments]] |  **REJECT** | La [[Comments]] di Marc Pantel e' in ritardo. Doveva arrivare il [[09-04-2023]] Inviata la [[mail]] di remind il [[24-04-2023]] |
		  | ==SCICO-D-22-00348== | Reject | Reject | Major | **REJECT** ||
		  | ==SCICO-D-22-00347== | Major | Major |  | **MAJOR** | Gli autori stanno lavorando sulla revisione che dovrebbe arrivare il [[05-05-2023]]. Arrivata la revision e rimandato il [[Paper]] [[AI]] revisori il giorno [[17-05-2023]] |
		  | ==SCICO-D-22-00341== | Minor | Major |  | **MINOR** ||
		  | ==[[SCICO-D-22-00339]]== | Major | Reject|  | **MAJOR**||
		  | ==SCICO-D-22-00310== | Major | Reject |  | **Reject** | Ho chiesto a Michel di rivedere la [[Comments]] il giorno [[24-04-2023]] |
		  | [[#red]]==TODO  SCICO-D-22-00363== | Minor | Under [[Comments]] |  |  | La [[Comments]] di Elvinia dovrebbe arrivare il [[29-04-2023]] Ho spostato la [[deadline-submission]] al [[12-05-2023]] |
		  | SCICO-D-22-0033 | Minor | Major | | | La [[Comments]] di Juri dovrebbe arrivare il [[03-05-2023]] Ho spostato la [[deadline-submission]] al [[10-05-2023]] |
		  |SCICO-D-22-00335R1 ||||[[#green]]==ACCEPT== ||
		-
-
-