-
full-title:: LEV4REC: A feature-based approach to engineering RSSEs
type:: [[JournalPaper]]
external-links:: [MDEGroup/SoSyM-LEV4REC (github.com)](https://github.com/MDEGroup/SoSyM-LEV4REC) [LEV4REC_Sosym_Reviews - Google Docs](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1y1KsDSZUju1MnMyvZM41YYDhyGvQBzVZzq52_qxRbdU/edit#heading=h.20hmz923tktr)
todoist:: https://todoist.com/showTask?id=6718800976
year:: 2023
tentative-submission-deadline:: [[04-09-2023]]
status:: [[SUBMITTED]] 
venue:: [[COLA]] 
date-submitted:: [[22-11-2023]] 
priority:: 
progress:: {{renderer :todomaster}}

	- Confini del lavoro
	- Rinominare il tool
	- #+BEGIN_QUOTE
	  I recommend to add a scenario as a guiding line through the whole article which would explain step [[by]] step how to start]] from exploiting software requirements of the SR to develop and implement them using the low-code approach.
	  #+END_QUOTE
		- Explanatory / running rec sys developed with and without LEV4REC
			- We need to clarify the challenges one has to deal with while developing a [[RecSys]]
				- Probably we are not able to address all of them (report part of the ESEM paper)
				- The explanatory example should limit the presentation of the challenges that are addressed [[by]] the tool
	- Put the [[Paper]] in the scope of [[SOSYM]]
		- We could change the focus (even in the title) on the usage of MDE for supporting the development of [[RecSys]]
			- Essentially we are showin gan application of MDE for developing tools in the domain of [[RecSys]]
	- WE claim **domain** independence!!!!
		- How to convince the reader about such a claim?
		- The best is to remove / reduce such a clain and list the domains that we can cover. In other words what are the characteristcs of the [[RecSys]] that we support?
			- We cannot mention specific domains, but we should chracterize the [[RecSys]] (from a component or structure point of view) that we support. For instance, in terms of algorithms we currently support only .....
			- On the other end it's important to stress the constraint management aspects (this is the main novelty)
				- We could even promote this aspect as main goal of the [[Paper]] / approach
		- The domain concept has to be removed from the [[Paper]]. WE need to show what are the main ingredients of [[RecSys]] and how we enable / manage their composition and configuration
	- How to answer [[Comments]] like:
		- ** At this point, I do not know precisely how to transpose the "last lines I already typed before my cursor". Is this enough to use your approach? Or do I need more refined specification? This is where a guiding scenario should be used.**
		- In my opinion here we should show how the developer is supposed to refine / finalize the [[code]] generated [[by]] the approach. How to accept user customizations / development ?
	- ** I think that RQ1 is enough for the validation if you are more systematic about "existing recommender systems". **
		- systematic means that the considered [[recsys]] are different with respect to some peculiar characteristics that should be introduced when writing the content replacing the domain aspect above
	- #+BEGIN_QUOTE
	  Il target del lavoro e' uno sviluppatore di sistemi di raccomandazione
	  #+END_QUOTE
		- Quali sono le challenges che attualmente deve affrontare?
			- Difficolta nello gestire le varie dipendenze tra algoritmi, dati, encoding, pre-processi (noi la risolviamo con il feature e vincoli)
	- ### Related works
		- ![Softw Pract Exp - 2022 - Savary‐Leblanc - Software assistants in software engineering  A systematic mapping study.pdf](../assets/Softw_Pract_Exp_-_2022_-_Savary‐Leblanc_-_Software_assistants_in_software_engineering_A_systematic_mapping_study_1684241801009_0.pdf)
	- ### Tasks
		- DONE Lavorare su abstract [[01-09-2023]]
		- DONE RIvedere introduction [[01-09-2023]]
		- DONE Rivedere sesione 2 [[01-09-2023]]
		- DONE Rivedere sezione 3 [[01-09-2023]]
		- DONE Rivedere sezione 4 [[02-09-2023]]
		- DONE Rivedere sezione 5 [[02-09-2023]]
		- DONE Rivedere sezione 6 [[02-09-2023]]
		- DONE Rivedere sezione 7 [[04-09-2023]]
		- DONE Rivedere sezione 8 [[04-09-2023]]
	-