type:: [[REVIEWS]]
tags:: 
year:: 2026
venue:: [[ICSE2026-WS]] 
full-title:: Bridging the gap between industry and academia: sustainability in LLM-assisted software engineering
date-start:: [[23-11-2025]] - 16:56
date-submitted::
external-links::
status:: [[DONE]] 
deadline-submission:: 
file:: [[@Bridging the gap between industry and academia: sustainability in LLM-assisted software engineering]] 
parent::
todoist:: https://app.todoist.com/app/task/27-bridging-the-gap-between-industry-and-academia-sustainability-in-llm-assisted-6fGCcw4wV8fQW9qc

	- ### [[Comments]]
		- The paper reports on the discussions held during the SILAS (Sustainability in LLM-assisted Software Development) workshop. It highlights sustainability challenges in LLM-based software engineering from both academic and industrial perspectives.
		- Although the topic is highly relevant and timely, the work suffers from issues in presentation and structure. The discussion is fragmented across the paper, and the narrative lacks a coherent flow. The choice of the three focus areas is not motivated. I suggest reorganizing the discussion section around clearly defined challenges and their corresponding research directions. A dedicated table mapping focus areas, identified challenges, and the research directions considered relevant during the SILAS event would greatly improve clarity.
		- Despite these structural issues, the paper addresses an important subject and can trigger interesting discussions during the workshop. I recommend revising the organization of the paper as suggested above.