logseq/pages/seaa_2024_paper_59.md

type:: REVIEWS tags:: year:: 2024 venue:: SEAA full-title:: Automated Integration of Safety Mechanisms into Functional Software for Safety-relevant Systems date-start:: 22-06-2024 - 10:38 date-submitted:: 22-06-2024 external-links:: status:: DONE deadline-submission:: 21-06-2024 file:: @Automated Integration of Safety Mechanisms into Functional Software for Safety-relevant Systems parent:: todoist:: https://app.todoist.com/app/task/59-rolf-schmedes-gregor-nitsche-and-kim-gruettner-automated-integration-of-safet-6VV8J9fPQqWpfw6c

- ### [[Highlights]]
- ### [[Comments]]
	- The paper presents a model-based approach to automate the integration of safety mechanisms into functional software, particularly for safety-relevant systems. The authors have developed a prototype of the approach, which permits developers to create an abstract model of the functional input source code. A subsequent code generation process is applied to integrate calls to software safety mechanism libraries automatically.
	- The paper is overall interesting and well-written. The technical parts are convincing, even though I have some concerns about the novelty of the proposed approach. The proposed methodology is highly similar to AOP, as discussed in the related work section. The strenghts and limitations of the propsed approach with respect to AOP are not convincly discussed. The authors claim that the proposed approach "offers a better compromise between complexity and effectiveness." and that "the main distinction from AOP is the combined, holistic view of functional source code, safety mechanisms, and the targeted hardware platform." However, such claims look generic and are not justified by limiting the novelty of the work. To make the paper more robust, I suggest discussing the applicability of some AOP approaches using the same explanatory example and highlighting their limitations, justifying the need for the proposed methodology.
- ### [[REVIEWS/Notes]]
- ### YELLOW CONCERNS
  background-color:: yellow
	- {{query (and [[ffd400]] [[seaa_2024_paper_59]] )}}
	  collapsed:: true
- ### ❓️Questions
	- {{query (and [[question]] [[seaa_2024_paper_59]] )[[question]]}}
	  query-table:: true
	  query-properties:: [:block]