logseq/pages/icse2023-review-1123-metareview.md

• On the positive side, reviewers found that the paper is about a relevant problem and appreciated the effort that the authors have made to create the benchmark dataset. However, on the negative side, the paper is not always easy to read. Many parts of the article need details and clarifications, resulting in a challenging to understand work. Reviewers unanimously agreed that the manuscript is not ready for ICSE 2023 and hope that the provided feedback will be beneficial to resubmit it elsewhere.
• —

• Strengths

  • Relevant problem
  • Encouraging evaluation results
  • Availability of an appendix including a replication package

• Weaknesses

  • The paper is not always easy to read
  • Lack of an explanatory example that might easy the understanding of the peculiar aspects of the proposed solution