Files
logseq/pages/ICSE2023-REVIEW-1237-METAREVIEW.md
T
2025-06-02 17:15:13 +02:00

564 B
Raw Blame History

  • On the positive side, reviewers found that the paper is about a relevant and challenging problem, and the proposed solution is implemented in realistic contexts. However, on the negative side, the approach is not clearly described, the evaluation is not convincing and based on RQs that need to be more specific. The authors response did not help to make reviewers change their evaluation. Therefore, reviewers unanimously agreed that the manuscript is not ready for ICSE 2023 and hope that the provided feedback will be beneficial to resubmit it elsewhere.