After rebase
This commit is contained in:
@@ -5,7 +5,7 @@ boox-notes::  (priority A))}}
|
||||
query-table:: true
|
||||
query-properties:: [:block :todoist-desc :todoist-id]
|
||||
- [[P2]]
|
||||
- {{query (and (task TODO) (priority B))}}
|
||||
query-table:: true
|
||||
query-properties:: [:block :todoist-desc]
|
||||
-
|
||||
- TODO Fare timesheets
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/ILIRIAN-COLLABORATION]]
|
||||
- TODO [[EditoringChairing/SOSYM-AI-MDE-SpecialIssue]]
|
||||
- TODO Literature review on adversarial ML for SE
|
||||
todoist-id:: [6841676473](https://todoist.com/app/task/6841676473)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: [Literature Review - Online LaTeX Editor Overleaf](https://www.overleaf.com/project/643e68c8a424e0027e19fc5d)
|
||||
- TODO Finalizzazione questione documentale
|
||||
- TODO [#B] [[PAPERS/DSL-FOR-IOT-TESTING]]
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/SSTD-LLMS]]
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/JSS-2024-PERFORMANCE-TEST-COVERAGE]]
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/SOSYM-EXPERT-VOICE-2024-ML-EVOLUTION]]
|
||||
- DONE Visita Riccardo
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: http://s.diruscio.org/u9fPP
|
||||
todoist-id:: [7602643924](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/7602643924)
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/2024-ONTOLOGY-AI]]
|
||||
todoist-id:: [7658261760](https://todoist.com/app/task/7658261760)
|
||||
- TODO NIER paper on how our two-level agent architecture
|
||||
- TODO [#C] [[PAPERS/2024-BiasInRSSEwithLLM]]
|
||||
todoist-id:: [7688827022](https://todoist.com/app/task/7688827022)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: [https://github.com/MDEGroup/BiasInRSSEwithLLM](https://github.com/MDEGroup/BiasInRSSEwithLLM)
|
||||
- TODO [#B] [FRINGE] Collaborazione su Fairness Mutation/Metamorphic Testing?
|
||||
- TODO [[EditoringChairing/2024-MODELS-WS-LOWCODE]]
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/2024-TESORO]]
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/TOSEM-2024-0258]]
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/AML4SE]]
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8113443070](https://todoist.com/app/task/8113443070)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: [AMLinRSSE - Online LaTeX Editor Overleaf](https://www.overleaf.com/project/66683cbaf1ed22bc12efee72)
|
||||
- DONE [#B] popup UnivAQ Street Science 2024
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: http://s.diruscio.org/eTBkR
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8117885918](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8117885918)
|
||||
:LOGBOOK:
|
||||
CLOCK: [2025-05-10 Sat 22:52:25]--[2025-05-10 Sat 22:52:27] => 00:00:02
|
||||
:END:
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/BADGES-IMPACT]]
|
||||
- TODO [#C] Convenzione Erasmus Nazionale
|
||||
- DONE [#A] [[PAPERS/JSS-SATD]]
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: http://s.diruscio.org/bWUfi
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8230073873](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8230073873)
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/EMELIOT-EXPERIMENT]]
|
||||
- DONE Career Day 24
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: http://s.diruscio.org/Y20BN
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8359671703](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8359671703)
|
||||
- TODO Panel Invitation (MODELS 2024)
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/FSE2024-UserStories]]
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8407326252](https://todoist.com/app/task/8407326252)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: http://s.diruscio.org/fcx9l
|
||||
- DONE [#A] [ICSE 2025, Research Track] Review Assignment and Instructions (Half Review Deadline: *Aug 30*)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: [http://s.diruscio.org/vMkXT](http://s.diruscio.org/vMkXT)
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8286706547](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8286706547)
|
||||
- DONE [#A] Progressione Phuong ad Associato
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: http://s.diruscio.org/hJoCt
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8419941589](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8419941589)
|
||||
- DONE [#A] Notifica nomina commissione RTD/A S.S.D INFO-01/A (Progetto MATTERS, Allegato A del Bando di selezione)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: http://s.diruscio.org/Z3tSx
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8424508957](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8424508957)
|
||||
- TODO Orientamento 2026 PNRR - Anno 24/25
|
||||
- DONE [#B] Progressione seconda fascia Phuong Nguyen
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: http://s.diruscio.org/MjM5n
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8427313493](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8427313493)
|
||||
SCHEDULED: <2025-01-10 Fri>
|
||||
- DONE [#A] Conscorso RTD/a MATTERS
|
||||
todoist-desc:: ✉: http://s.diruscio.org/ouj19
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8434113580](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8434113580)
|
||||
SCHEDULED: <2024-11-08 Fri 11:10>
|
||||
- TODO Ridefinizione Piano Formativo e regole di riconoscimento CFU
|
||||
- TODO [#B] [[PAPERS/2024-AMLinRSSE]]
|
||||
SCHEDULED: <2025-05-26 Mon>
|
||||
- DONE [Lavoro Davide Sciarra e Giovanni Sicchio](https://outlook.office365.com/owa/?ItemID=AAkALgAAAAAAHYQDEapmEc2byACqAC%2FEWg0AjoVpQvBez0Ss5ZY2WGWEJgAHeU%2BoMgAA&exvsurl=1&viewmodel=ReadMessageItem)
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8558858426](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8558858426)
|
||||
- DONE [#A] [[PAPERS/TOSEM-FAIRNESS]]
|
||||
todoist-desc:: [[TOSEM] Towards Early Detection of Algorithmic Bias from Dataset's Bias Symptoms: An Empirical Study - Online LaTeX Editor Overleaf](https://www.overleaf.com/project/65b7d77455b46f44b87e2331)
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8565953885](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8565953885)
|
||||
SCHEDULED: <2025-01-14 Tue 12:00>
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/SANER2025-FAIRNESS]]
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/SANER-2025-Popbias-LLM]]
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/MSR-2025-CodeXHug-dataset]]
|
||||
- TODO Nuova edizione del PinKamp
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8644892780](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8644892780)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: From: giuseppe.dellapenna@univaq.it
|
||||
- TODO ICSE 2026 Program Committee
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/Experience-Report-to-EMSE]]
|
||||
- TODO [[PAPERS/FSE2025-NIER]]
|
||||
- TODO [#C] Dottorato industriale riservato a dipendenti
|
||||
- TODO Esplorare e approfondire gli aspetti fondamentali e pratici dei large language models
|
||||
SCHEDULED: <2025-05-25 Sun>
|
||||
- TODO [#C] [[PAPERS/JOURNAL-LLMS4Edelta]]
|
||||
- TODO Richiesta afferenza al Collegio di Mauro Cappelli, ricercatore all’Enea
|
||||
- TODO [#C] Vedere per compenso per la De Masi
|
||||
- TODO [#B] [[PAPERS/Journal-Green-Paper]]
|
||||
- TODO [#A] Rivedere Composizione Collegio
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8750396305](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8750396305)
|
||||
- TODO [#C] [[PAPERS/ABSTRACT-ENGINEERING]]
|
||||
- TODO [#C] [[PAPERS/TOSEM2025-TESORO]]
|
||||
- TODO [#B] [R: Scheda XLI ciclo e richieste di afferenza al Collegio](https://outlook.office365.com/owa/?ItemID=AAkALgAAAAAAHYQDEapmEc2byACqAC%2FEWg0AjoVpQvBez0Ss5ZY2WGWEJgAHueDXAQAA&exvsurl=1&viewmodel=ReadMessageItem)
|
||||
- TODO [#B] Informiamo che entro e non oltre il ciascun Coordinatore dovrà caricare sulla piattaforma telematica dedicata: - il verbale del collegio dei docenti con esplicita ammissione all’esame finale; - la copia della tesi finale del dottorando; - il verbale della commissione dell’esame finale.
|
||||
SCHEDULED: <2025-07-31 Thu>
|
||||
- TODO [#B] MODELS Journal-First-track + 1 more
|
||||
SCHEDULED: <2025-05-26 Mon>
|
||||
- TODO Revision of manuscript #EMSE-D-25-00044
|
||||
- TODO [#B] [[PAPERS/MAS-4-POPULARITY-BIAS]]
|
||||
- TODO [#B] [ICSE 2026, Research Track] Review Assignment and Instructions (Half Review Deadline: *Apr 18*; All reviews deadline: May 16)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: From: noreply-icse2026@hotcrp.com
|
||||
todoist-id:: [9001461730](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/9001461730)
|
||||
- TODO Dottorato industriale
|
||||
todoist-id:: [9006116046](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/9006116046)
|
||||
SCHEDULED: <2025-05-22 Thu>
|
||||
- DONE [#B] Models Conference 2025
|
||||
id:: 682ecc99-b356-4086-9ff8-4e4736018009
|
||||
SCHEDULED✔️ <2025-05-26 Mon>
|
||||
:LOGBOOK:
|
||||
CLOCK: [2025-05-24 Sat 22:02:34]--[2025-05-24 Sat 22:02:35] => 00:00:01
|
||||
CLOCK: [2025-05-24 Sat 22:02:52]--[2025-05-24 Sat 22:02:52] => 00:00:00
|
||||
:END:
|
||||
- DONE Review MODELS 2025 conference submissions
|
||||
id:: 6832257a-4373-4560-a7e2-79fba9f4c9e6
|
||||
:LOGBOOK:
|
||||
CLOCK: [2025-05-24 Sat 22:02:27]--[2025-05-24 Sat 22:02:28] => 00:00:01
|
||||
:END:
|
||||
- TODO [#B] [[PAPERS/2025-SEAA-CodeXHug]]
|
||||
- DONE [[PAPERS/2025-Survey-MOSAICO]]
|
||||
id:: 6832257a-63a4-4c89-8353-25f0e94caa51
|
||||
- TODO [#B] Migliorare situazione economica dottorandi
|
||||
- TODO [#B] Sinergia con GSSI
|
||||
- TODO [#A] [[PAPERS/MOSAICO-Technical-Report]]
|
||||
todoist-id:: [9187744429](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/9187744429)
|
||||
- TODO [#A] SLIDES DI PRESENTAZIONE
|
||||
todoist-id:: [9193848277](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/9193848277)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: Con HOWTO etc.
|
||||
- TODO [#A] MODELS Journal-First-track + 1 more
|
||||
todoist-id:: [8933176944](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/8933176944)
|
||||
todoist-desc:: From: noreply@researchr.org
|
||||
SCHEDULED: <2025-05-25 Sun>
|
||||
- TODO [#A] [[PAPERS/2025-SEAA-CodeXHug]]
|
||||
todoist-id:: [9123770472](https://app.todoist.com/app/task/9123770472)
|
||||
@@ -1,131 +0,0 @@
|
||||
template:: JOURNAL-TEMPLATE
|
||||
|
||||
- #.tabular
|
||||
- ### 🗒️Notes
|
||||
-
|
||||
- ### 📜Reviews
|
||||
- {{query (and [[REVIEWS]] (or (property :date-end <%today%>) (property :date-start <%today%>) (property :date-submitted <%today%>)))}}
|
||||
query-table:: true
|
||||
query-properties:: [:file :year :venue :deadline]
|
||||
- ### ⤴️Omnivore readings
|
||||
- {{query (and (property :source [[Omnivore]]) (or (property :deadline <%today%>) (property :date-saved <%today%>) (property :date-archived <%today%>)))}}
|
||||
query-table:: true
|
||||
query-properties:: [:labels :state :full-title]
|
||||
-
|
||||
- type:: [[JournalPaper]], [[conferencepaper]], [[WorkshopPaper]], [[Bookchapter]]
|
||||
template:: PAPERS
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
full-title::
|
||||
external-links::
|
||||
todoist::
|
||||
year::
|
||||
date-start::
|
||||
status:: [[DOING]], [[DONE]], [[SUBMITTED]], [[REJECTED]] [[UNDER-REVISION]]
|
||||
venue::
|
||||
priority:: [[P1]] [[P2]] [[P3]] [[P4]]
|
||||
parent::
|
||||
leader::
|
||||
todoist::
|
||||
progress:: {{renderer :todomaster}}
|
||||
- #.tabular
|
||||
- ## MEETINGS
|
||||
- {{query (and <%current page%> (block-property :type [[meeting]]) (not (page <%current page%>)))}}
|
||||
- query-table:: true
|
||||
- ## READINGS
|
||||
- #+BEGIN_QUERY
|
||||
{:title "Related readings in Omnivore"
|
||||
:query [:find (pull ?b [*] )
|
||||
:in $ ?current-page
|
||||
:where
|
||||
[?b :block/page ?p]
|
||||
[?p :block/name ?p-name]
|
||||
[?b :block/content ?c]
|
||||
[(clojure.string/includes? ?c ?current-page)]
|
||||
[(clojure.string/includes? ?p-name "omnivore")]
|
||||
]
|
||||
:inputs [:current-page]}
|
||||
#+END_QUERY
|
||||
-
|
||||
- ## TASKs
|
||||
-
|
||||
- ## ❓️ QUESTIONS TO ANSWER
|
||||
{{query (and [[question]]<%current page%>)}}
|
||||
- ## [[PAPERS/NOTES]]
|
||||
-
|
||||
- type:: [[weblink]]
|
||||
template:: WEBLINK
|
||||
source::
|
||||
tags:: [[readingnotes]]
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
- type:: [[CAD]]
|
||||
template:: CAD
|
||||
corso:: [[Ingegneria Informatica]], [[Informatica]], [[TEACHING/DSU-S3S]], [[TEACHING/DSU-S3F]]
|
||||
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
- type:: [[REVIEWS]]
|
||||
tags::
|
||||
year::
|
||||
venue::
|
||||
template:: REVIEW
|
||||
full-title::
|
||||
date-start:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
date-submitted::
|
||||
external-links::
|
||||
status:: [[DOING]]
|
||||
deadline-submission::
|
||||
file::
|
||||
parent::
|
||||
todoist::
|
||||
- ### [[Highlights]]
|
||||
- ### [[Comments]]
|
||||
- ### [[REVIEWS/Notes]]
|
||||
- ### YELLOW CONCERNS
|
||||
background-color:: yellow
|
||||
- {{query (and [[ffd400]] <%current page%> )}}
|
||||
collapsed:: true
|
||||
- ### ❓️Questions
|
||||
- {{query (and [[question]] <%current page%> )[[question]]}}
|
||||
query-table:: true
|
||||
query-properties:: [:block]
|
||||
- type:: [[Contact]]
|
||||
page-type:: [[people]]
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
template:: CONTACT
|
||||
name::
|
||||
struttura::
|
||||
email::
|
||||
- type:: [[meeting]]
|
||||
template:: ConsiglioDisim
|
||||
external-links::
|
||||
tags:: [[SERVICES/ConsiglioDisim]] [[Convocazioni]]
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
duration-min::
|
||||
file-brogliaccio::
|
||||
file-odg::
|
||||
- type:: [[meeting]]
|
||||
template:: MEETING
|
||||
external-links::
|
||||
tags::
|
||||
people::
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
duration::
|
||||
- template:: VENUE
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
full-title::
|
||||
link::
|
||||
type:: [[JOURNAL]] [[CONFERENCE]] [[WORKSHOP]]
|
||||
ranking-link::
|
||||
- template:: QUERY-QUESTIONS
|
||||
template-including-parent:: false
|
||||
- ### Questions
|
||||
- {{query (and [[question]] <%current page%> )[[question]]}}
|
||||
- template:: QUERY-IDEAS
|
||||
template-including-parent:: false
|
||||
- ### Ideas
|
||||
- {{query (and [[Ideas]] <%current page%>)}}
|
||||
- template:: QUERY-TASKS
|
||||
template-including-parent:: false
|
||||
- ### TASKS
|
||||
- {{query (and <%current page%> (task TODO DOING) (not [[GOALS-TODOIST]]))}}
|
||||
- template:: BOOX-TODAY-NOTES
|
||||
- 
|
||||
@@ -1,131 +0,0 @@
|
||||
template:: JOURNAL-TEMPLATE
|
||||
|
||||
- #.tabular
|
||||
- ### 🗒️Notes
|
||||
-
|
||||
- ### 📜Reviews
|
||||
- {{query (and [[REVIEWS]] (or (property :date-end <%today%>) (property :date-start <%today%>) (property :date-submitted <%today%>)))}}
|
||||
query-table:: true
|
||||
query-properties:: [:file :year :venue :deadline]
|
||||
- ### ⤴️Omnivore readings
|
||||
- {{query (and (property :source [[Omnivore]]) (or (property :deadline <%today%>) (property :date-saved <%today%>) (property :date-archived <%today%>)))}}
|
||||
query-table:: true
|
||||
query-properties:: [:labels :state :full-title]
|
||||
-
|
||||
- type:: [[JournalPaper]], [[conferencepaper]], [[WorkshopPaper]], [[Bookchapter]]
|
||||
template:: PAPERS
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
full-title::
|
||||
external-links::
|
||||
todoist::
|
||||
year::
|
||||
date-start::
|
||||
status:: [[DOING]], [[DONE]], [[SUBMITTED]], [[REJECTED]] [[UNDER-REVISION]]
|
||||
venue::
|
||||
priority:: [[P1]] [[P2]] [[P3]] [[P4]]
|
||||
parent::
|
||||
leader::
|
||||
todoist::
|
||||
progress:: {{renderer :todomaster}}
|
||||
- #.tabular
|
||||
- ## MEETINGS
|
||||
- {{query (and <%current page%> (block-property :type [[meeting]]) (not (page <%current page%>)))}}
|
||||
- query-table:: true
|
||||
- ## READINGS
|
||||
- #+BEGIN_QUERY
|
||||
{:title "Related readings in Omnivore"
|
||||
:query [:find (pull ?b [*] )
|
||||
:in $ ?current-page
|
||||
:where
|
||||
[?b :block/page ?p]
|
||||
[?p :block/name ?p-name]
|
||||
[?b :block/content ?c]
|
||||
[(clojure.string/includes? ?c ?current-page)]
|
||||
[(clojure.string/includes? ?p-name "omnivore")]
|
||||
]
|
||||
:inputs [:current-page]}
|
||||
#+END_QUERY
|
||||
-
|
||||
- ## TASKs
|
||||
-
|
||||
- ## ❓️ QUESTIONS TO ANSWER
|
||||
{{query (and [[question]]<%current page%>)}}
|
||||
- ## [[PAPERS/NOTES]]
|
||||
-
|
||||
- type:: [[weblink]]
|
||||
template:: WEBLINK
|
||||
source::
|
||||
tags:: [[readingnotes]]
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
- type:: [[CAD]]
|
||||
template:: CAD
|
||||
corso:: [[Ingegneria Informatica]], [[Informatica]], [[TEACHING/DSU-S3S]], [[TEACHING/DSU-S3F]]
|
||||
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
- type:: [[REVIEWS]]
|
||||
tags::
|
||||
year::
|
||||
venue::
|
||||
template:: REVIEW
|
||||
full-title::
|
||||
date-start:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
date-submitted::
|
||||
external-links::
|
||||
status:: [[DOING]]
|
||||
deadline-submission::
|
||||
file::
|
||||
parent::
|
||||
todoist::
|
||||
- ### [[Highlights]]
|
||||
- ### [[Comments]]
|
||||
- ### [[REVIEWS/Notes]]
|
||||
- ### YELLOW CONCERNS
|
||||
background-color:: yellow
|
||||
- {{query (and [[ffd400]] <%current page%> )}}
|
||||
collapsed:: true
|
||||
- ### ❓️Questions
|
||||
- {{query (and [[question]] <%current page%> )[[question]]}}
|
||||
query-table:: true
|
||||
query-properties:: [:block]
|
||||
- type:: [[Contact]]
|
||||
page-type:: [[people]]
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
template:: CONTACT
|
||||
name::
|
||||
struttura::
|
||||
email::
|
||||
- type:: [[meeting]]
|
||||
template:: ConsiglioDisim
|
||||
external-links::
|
||||
tags:: [[SERVICES/ConsiglioDisim]] [[Convocazioni]]
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
duration-min::
|
||||
file-brogliaccio::
|
||||
file-odg::
|
||||
- type:: [[meeting]]
|
||||
template:: MEETING
|
||||
external-links::
|
||||
tags::
|
||||
people::
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
duration::
|
||||
- template:: VENUE
|
||||
date:: <%today%> - <%time%>
|
||||
full-title::
|
||||
link::
|
||||
type:: [[JOURNAL]] [[CONFERENCE]] [[WORKSHOP]]
|
||||
ranking-link::
|
||||
- template:: QUERY-QUESTIONS
|
||||
template-including-parent:: false
|
||||
- ### Questions
|
||||
- {{query (and [[question]] <%current page%> )[[question]]}}
|
||||
- template:: QUERY-IDEAS
|
||||
template-including-parent:: false
|
||||
- ### Ideas
|
||||
- {{query (and [[Ideas]] <%current page%>)}}
|
||||
- template:: QUERY-TASKS
|
||||
template-including-parent:: false
|
||||
- ### TASKS
|
||||
- {{query (and <%current page%> (task TODO DOING) (not [[GOALS-TODOIST]]))}}
|
||||
- template:: BOOX-TODAY-NOTES
|
||||
- 
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
|
||||
collapsed:: true
|
||||
type:: [[REVIEWS]]
|
||||
tags::
|
||||
year:: 2025
|
||||
venue:: [[SEAA]]
|
||||
full-title:: An agent design pattern catalogue for the entanglement of Digital Twins
|
||||
date-start:: [[22-06-2025]] - 10:06
|
||||
date-submitted::
|
||||
external-links::
|
||||
status:: [[DONE]]
|
||||
deadline-submission::
|
||||
file:: [[@An agent design pattern catalogue for the entanglement of Digital Twins]]
|
||||
parent::
|
||||
todoist:: https://app.todoist.com/app/task/12-elena-pretel-elena-navarro-victor-lopez-jaquero-pascual-gonzalez-and-schahram-6c9VMX9wg7XQVxh6
|
||||
|
||||
- ### [[Highlights]]
|
||||
- ### [[Comments]]
|
||||
- The paper presents a catalog of patterns to support the design of digital twins according to different levels of entanglement between physical entities and the corresponding digital twin.
|
||||
|
||||
My main concerns about the paper are its presentation and limited discussion of the strengths and limitations of the presented design patterns. In particular:
|
||||
- While the catalog discusses well-known architectural patterns such as Observer, Publish-Subscribe, and Event Dispatcher, it remains unclear to what extent these have been modified or extended to suit the particular challenges of DTs. The paper mentions that the patterns are "adapted" to the context of DTs, but does not explain what these adaptations consist of. Are they structural, behavioral, related to scalability, or something else? Without this clarification, the reader is left questioning whether the contribution is a novel engineering solution or simply a "DT reinterpretation" of existing work.
|
||||
- Another concern arises concerning the Grounded Theory (GT) methodology. The paper claims that its main contribution lies in combining SLR with GT to enrich the catalog of patterns. However, it remains unclear why the prior SLR conducted by the authors did not already address the entanglement aspect and what specific new insights were made possible exclusively through the GT component. This point is critical because it relates to the proposed pattern catalog's originality and empirical foundation. What was missing in the original SLR, and how was GT specifically employed to address those gaps?
|
||||
- The paper introduces a decision model to guide architects in selecting the appropriate agent patterns to realize a desired level of entanglement. This idea is conceptually promising, but the practical details are not given. At what stage of the design process should this design model be used? What form does the model take (e.g., decision tree, rule set, software tool)? Providing an illustrative example would significantly help in assessing its relevance and usability.
|
||||
|
||||
In summary, while the paper raises important points about the use of MAS patterns in DT engineering and introduces potentially useful structuring elements (like a classification of entanglement levels and a decision model), its contributions are affected by the lack of specificity regarding pattern adaptation, methodological gaps in justifying the GT component, and limited elaboration on how its proposed decision model can be adopted in practice.
|
||||
- ---
|
||||
-
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user